척추 수술에 사용되는 나사못의 반복 삽입과 인출이 인장항력에 미치는 영향 : 생체 역학적 연구 The Effect of Repetitive Insertion and Pullout of Spinal Screws on Pullout Resistance : A Biomechanical Study원문보기
목적 : 최근 척추 수술에 나사못을 사용하는 빈도와 범위가 넓어 지고 있는데 때로 수술 중 한번 삽입하였던 나사못을 다시 사용하는 경우가 있다. 인체 골과 타이타늄의 탄성계수가 크게 차이 나지만 반복 삽입 과정에서 나사못의 이가 손상될 가능성이 있다. 저자들은 나사못의 반복 삽입이 나사못의 인출 저항에 미치는 영향을 조사하였다. 방법 : 각각 6개의 세가지 다른 종류 cortical lateral mass screw, cancellous lateral mass screw and cervical vertebral body screw의 나사못을 시험하였다. 나사못을 인체의 골과 비슷한 밀도의 인공합성골에 삽입하였으며 삽입 중 삽입력을 측정하였고 그 후 Instron(Model TT-D, Canton, MA)을 이용하여 2.4mm의 속도로 인출하여 인장항력을 digital oscilloscope에 기록하였다. 위의 과정을 3회 반복하여 기록한 뒤 나사못을 광학 현미경으로 확대하여 관찰하였다. 결과 : cortical lateral mass screws의 평균 인장항력(1회인장 시험 $185.66N{\pm}42.60$, 2회 인장시험$167.10N{\pm}27.01$, 3회인장 시험 $162.52N{\pm}23.83$ : p=0.03)과 cervical vertebral body screws ($386.0N{\pm}24.1$, $360.2N{\pm}17.5$ and $330.9N{\pm}16.7$ : p=0.0024)은 반복하여 삽입, 인장 검사 할 때 마다 감소하였으나 cancellous lateral mass screws의 평균 인장항력($194.00N{\pm}36.47$, $219.24N{\pm}26.58$ and $199.49N{\pm}36.63$ : p=0.24)은 감소하지 않았다. 전자현미경 소견에서 나사이의 끝이 무디어지고 표면이 문드러진 것을 관찰할 수 있었다. 결론 : 일부 나사못을 반복하여 삽입한 후 나사못의 인장항력이 감소되었으므로 수술중 여러번 삽입하였던 나사못은 최종 구조물에 사용되지 않아야 한다.
목적 : 최근 척추 수술에 나사못을 사용하는 빈도와 범위가 넓어 지고 있는데 때로 수술 중 한번 삽입하였던 나사못을 다시 사용하는 경우가 있다. 인체 골과 타이타늄의 탄성계수가 크게 차이 나지만 반복 삽입 과정에서 나사못의 이가 손상될 가능성이 있다. 저자들은 나사못의 반복 삽입이 나사못의 인출 저항에 미치는 영향을 조사하였다. 방법 : 각각 6개의 세가지 다른 종류 cortical lateral mass screw, cancellous lateral mass screw and cervical vertebral body screw의 나사못을 시험하였다. 나사못을 인체의 골과 비슷한 밀도의 인공합성골에 삽입하였으며 삽입 중 삽입력을 측정하였고 그 후 Instron(Model TT-D, Canton, MA)을 이용하여 2.4mm의 속도로 인출하여 인장항력을 digital oscilloscope에 기록하였다. 위의 과정을 3회 반복하여 기록한 뒤 나사못을 광학 현미경으로 확대하여 관찰하였다. 결과 : cortical lateral mass screws의 평균 인장항력(1회인장 시험 $185.66N{\pm}42.60$, 2회 인장시험 $167.10N{\pm}27.01$, 3회인장 시험 $162.52N{\pm}23.83$ : p=0.03)과 cervical vertebral body screws ($386.0N{\pm}24.1$, $360.2N{\pm}17.5$ and $330.9N{\pm}16.7$ : p=0.0024)은 반복하여 삽입, 인장 검사 할 때 마다 감소하였으나 cancellous lateral mass screws의 평균 인장항력($194.00N{\pm}36.47$, $219.24N{\pm}26.58$ and $199.49N{\pm}36.63$ : p=0.24)은 감소하지 않았다. 전자현미경 소견에서 나사이의 끝이 무디어지고 표면이 문드러진 것을 관찰할 수 있었다. 결론 : 일부 나사못을 반복하여 삽입한 후 나사못의 인장항력이 감소되었으므로 수술중 여러번 삽입하였던 나사못은 최종 구조물에 사용되지 않아야 한다.
Object : The clinical uses of screws are increasing with broader applications in spinal disorders. When screws are inserted repeatedly to achieve optimal position, tips of screw pitch may become damaged during insertion even though there are significant differences in the moduli of elasticity betwee...
Object : The clinical uses of screws are increasing with broader applications in spinal disorders. When screws are inserted repeatedly to achieve optimal position, tips of screw pitch may become damaged during insertion even though there are significant differences in the moduli of elasticity between bone and titanium. The effect of repeated screw insertion on pullout resistance was investigated. Methods : Three different titanium screws(cortical lateral mass screw, cancellous lateral mass screw and cervical vertebral body screw) were inserted into the synthetic cancellous material and then extracted axially at a rate of 2.4mm/min using Instron(Model TT-D, Canton, MA). Each set of screws was inserted and pulled out three times. There were six screws in each group. The insertional torque was measured with a torque wrench during insertion. Pullout strength was recorded with a digital oscilloscope. Results : The mean pullout force measurements for the cortical lateral mass screws($185.66N{\pm}42.60$, $167.10N{\pm}27.01$ and $162.52 N{\pm}23.83$ for first, second and third pullout respectively : p=0.03) and the cervical vertebral body screws($386.0N{\pm}24.1$, $360.2N{\pm}17.5$ and $330.9N{\pm}16.7$ : p=0.0024) showed consecutive decrease in pullout resistance after each pullout, whereas the cancellous lateral mass screws did not($194.00N{\pm}36.47$, $219.24N{\pm}26.58$ and 199.49N(36.63 : p=0.24). The SEM after insertion and pullout three times showed a blunting in the tip of the screw pitch and a smearing of the screw surface. Conclusions : Repetitive screw insertion and pullout resulted in the decrease of pullout resistance in certain screws possibly caused by blunting the screw tip. This means screw tips suffer deformations during either repeated insertion or pullout. Thus, the screws that have been inserted should not be used for the final construct.
Object : The clinical uses of screws are increasing with broader applications in spinal disorders. When screws are inserted repeatedly to achieve optimal position, tips of screw pitch may become damaged during insertion even though there are significant differences in the moduli of elasticity between bone and titanium. The effect of repeated screw insertion on pullout resistance was investigated. Methods : Three different titanium screws(cortical lateral mass screw, cancellous lateral mass screw and cervical vertebral body screw) were inserted into the synthetic cancellous material and then extracted axially at a rate of 2.4mm/min using Instron(Model TT-D, Canton, MA). Each set of screws was inserted and pulled out three times. There were six screws in each group. The insertional torque was measured with a torque wrench during insertion. Pullout strength was recorded with a digital oscilloscope. Results : The mean pullout force measurements for the cortical lateral mass screws($185.66N{\pm}42.60$, $167.10N{\pm}27.01$ and $162.52 N{\pm}23.83$ for first, second and third pullout respectively : p=0.03) and the cervical vertebral body screws($386.0N{\pm}24.1$, $360.2N{\pm}17.5$ and $330.9N{\pm}16.7$ : p=0.0024) showed consecutive decrease in pullout resistance after each pullout, whereas the cancellous lateral mass screws did not($194.00N{\pm}36.47$, $219.24N{\pm}26.58$ and 199.49N(36.63 : p=0.24). The SEM after insertion and pullout three times showed a blunting in the tip of the screw pitch and a smearing of the screw surface. Conclusions : Repetitive screw insertion and pullout resulted in the decrease of pullout resistance in certain screws possibly caused by blunting the screw tip. This means screw tips suffer deformations during either repeated insertion or pullout. Thus, the screws that have been inserted should not be used for the final construct.
* AI 자동 식별 결과로 적합하지 않은 문장이 있을 수 있으니, 이용에 유의하시기 바랍니다.
문제 정의
However, the effect of repetitive use of spinal screws on the screw pullout resistance has not been investigated. The goal of this study is to quantify the effect of repetitive insertion of spinal screws on screw pullout resistance.
대상 데이터
50 mm pitch length: DePuy-Acromed, Raynham, MA) were placed 10mm into the test material. Six cervical vertebral body screws(expandable screw with conical core diameter, 14 mm overall length, 4.0mm outer diameter and a 0.18mm pitch length：DOC ventral cervical stabilization system, DePuy-Acromed, Raynham, MA) were placed 12mm into the test material using platform. A commercially available torque screwdriver(0.
65mm pitch length：DePuyAcromed, Raynham, MA) were placed 10mm into the test material. Six cortical lateral mass screws(14mm overall length, 3.5 outer diameter, 2.0mm core diameter and a 0.50 mm pitch length: DePuy-Acromed, Raynham, MA) were placed 10mm into the test material. Six cervical vertebral body screws(expandable screw with conical core diameter, 14 mm overall length, 4.
Three different screws were tested：Six cancellous lateral mass screws(14mm overall length, 4mm outer diameter, 2,8mm core diameter and 1.65mm pitch length：DePuyAcromed, Raynham, MA) were placed 10mm into the test material. Six cortical lateral mass screws(14mm overall length, 3.
Uniform, rectangular blocks of synthetic cancellous material with a medium porosity and 0.24gm/cc of compressive performance(25×25×50mm) were used(General plastics Manufacturing Co., Tacoma, WA).
데이터처리
The statistical analysis comprised an ANOVA test. The results were confirmed with using a two-sided paired t-test. A level of 95% was considered to be statistically significant.
The screw pullout resistance and insertional torque for each study were then compared. The statistical analysis comprised an ANOVA test. The results were confirmed with using a two-sided paired t-test.
성능/효과
The authors think that repeated insertion rather than pullout caused the blunting that eventually leaded to the decrease in pullout resistance: (1) The SEM image of the tip implies that the tips of screw pitch were compressed rather than bent over. (2) The compressive force along the pitch can cause depression in the screw tips but the bending force across the screw pitch can’t possibly modify the contour of screw tip because the elasticity modulus of synthetic bone is much smaller than that of titanium. (3) Furthermore, the amount of decrease in pullout resistance was greater in screws in which the insertion torque was greater.
In the analysis of the results in pullout study, the cortical lateral mass screw and cervical vertebral body screws showed consecutive decrease in pullout resistance. ANOVA test showed a statistically significant decrease between all studies in cervical vertebral body screws and second and third study in cortical lateral mass screws.
※ AI-Helper는 부적절한 답변을 할 수 있습니다.