Purpose: This descriptive study aimed to explore nursing workplace spirituality, end-of-life care stress, and resilience as factors influencing compassion fatigue among nurses working in hospice and palliative care units. Methods: Data were collected using a self-report questionnaire completed by 14...
Purpose: This descriptive study aimed to explore nursing workplace spirituality, end-of-life care stress, and resilience as factors influencing compassion fatigue among nurses working in hospice and palliative care units. Methods: Data were collected using a self-report questionnaire completed by 146 nurses at 14 hospice and palliative care institutions across South Korea who had worked in a hospice and palliative care institution for at least 6 months and had experience providing end-of-life care. Data were collected from February 25, 2019 to April 12, 2019, and analyzed using SPSS for Windows version 18.0. As appropriate, descriptive statistics, the t-test, analysis of variance, the Scheffé test, Pearson correlation coefficients, and stepwise multiple regression were used. Results: The survey results showed that factors influencing compassion fatigue were resilience, subjective health status, current satisfaction with the hospice ward, and end-of-life care stress. Higher levels of resilience, a subjective health status of "healthy", high levels of current satisfaction with the hospice ward, and lower levels of end-of-life care stress were associated with lower levels of compassion fatigue, explaining 42.9% of the total variance. Conclusion: The results of this study suggest that resilience is an important factor mitigating compassion fatigue among nurses at hospice and palliative care institutions. Therefore, intervention programs should be developed to reduce compassion fatigue.
Purpose: This descriptive study aimed to explore nursing workplace spirituality, end-of-life care stress, and resilience as factors influencing compassion fatigue among nurses working in hospice and palliative care units. Methods: Data were collected using a self-report questionnaire completed by 146 nurses at 14 hospice and palliative care institutions across South Korea who had worked in a hospice and palliative care institution for at least 6 months and had experience providing end-of-life care. Data were collected from February 25, 2019 to April 12, 2019, and analyzed using SPSS for Windows version 18.0. As appropriate, descriptive statistics, the t-test, analysis of variance, the Scheffé test, Pearson correlation coefficients, and stepwise multiple regression were used. Results: The survey results showed that factors influencing compassion fatigue were resilience, subjective health status, current satisfaction with the hospice ward, and end-of-life care stress. Higher levels of resilience, a subjective health status of "healthy", high levels of current satisfaction with the hospice ward, and lower levels of end-of-life care stress were associated with lower levels of compassion fatigue, explaining 42.9% of the total variance. Conclusion: The results of this study suggest that resilience is an important factor mitigating compassion fatigue among nurses at hospice and palliative care institutions. Therefore, intervention programs should be developed to reduce compassion fatigue.
* AI 자동 식별 결과로 적합하지 않은 문장이 있을 수 있으니, 이용에 유의하시기 바랍니다.
문제 정의
Therefore, this study aimed to determine the factors affecting compassion fatigue among nurses working at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities. Furthermore, we sought to provide basic data for the development of interventions to prevent compassion fatigue among nurses working at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities.
This study was conducted to investigate relationships between nursing workplace spirituality, end-of-life care stress, resilience, and compassion fatigue among nurses working at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities and to examine the effects of these variables on compassion fatigue among them, thereby providing basic data for the development of interventions to prevent compassion fatigue among nurses working at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities.
제안 방법
For data collection, the researchers explained the purpose and process of the research to the head of the relevant medical institutions and obtained consent from the study partici- pants, after which the participants were asked to directly fill out structured, self-reported questionnaires. Data were collected from February 25, 2019, to April 12, 2019, and the data collection method was approved by the Institutional Review Board of K University in B Metropolitan City (IRB number: KU IRB 2018-0103).
In order to determine the factors influencing the participants’ compassion fatigue, stepwise multiple regression analysis was performed on the following general characteristics that were associated with compassion fatigue levels: age, work experi- ence, marital status, religiosity, bereavement experience within the last 1 year, current hospice ward satisfaction, the frequency of end-of-life care experience, subjective health status, nursing workplace spirituality, end-of-life care stress, and resilience. The most explanatory variable for compassion fatigue was resilience (β=-0.
It is a 40-item assessment tool consisting of 7 subscales, including negative attitudes of patient and his/her family members, difficulty of sharing time to the dying patient, burden about bereavement care, overloaded duty, humane relation conflict with dying patient, insufficiency in professional knowledge and skills, and conflict about medical limit. The tool uses a 5-point Likert scale, and a higher score indicates higher end-of-life care stress.
Data were collected from February 25, 2019, to April 12, 2019, and the data collection method was approved by the Institutional Review Board of K University in B Metropolitan City (IRB number: KU IRB 2018-0103). The questionnaire used for data collection included information on the study purpose, study participation period, procedures and methods, expected risks and benefits, personal data protection, compensation for losses associated with participation in the study, and withdrawal of consent. Written consent was obtained and voluntary participation was guaranteed from an ethical standpoint.
The tool has a total of 32 items and is composed of six subscales including interaction with job environment, meaning of nursing, inner self, relationship with colleagues, harmony between workplace and individual, and transcendence through nursing. It uses a 7-point Likert scale, and a higher score indicates higher nursing workplace spirituality.
This descriptive correlational study was conducted to identify the factors affecting compassion fatigue among nurses at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities.
대상 데이터
80, and 14 predictive factors assumed considering the 11 items on general characteristics and three independent variables, the minimum sample required was 135 people. Considering the potential for dropout, 149 questionnaires were distributed, of which 146 copies, excluding three with insufficient responses, were used for the final analysis.
structured, self-reported questionnaires. Data were collected from February 25, 2019, to April 12, 2019, and the data collection method was approved by the Institutional Review Board of K University in B Metropolitan City (IRB number: KU IRB 2018-0103). The questionnaire used for data collection included information on the study purpose, study participation period, procedures and methods, expected risks and benefits, personal data protection, compensation for losses associated with participation in the study, and withdrawal of consent.
0), which is a revised and supplemented version of the original tool developed by Figley [20]. The tool used in this study consists of a total of 20 items and includes two subscales (secondary traumatic stress and burn- out). The tool uses a 5-point Likert scale, and higher scores indicate higher levels of compassion fatigue.
the Ministry of Health and Welfare. They were selected using convenience sampling from 14 medical institutions nationwide (1 in city A, 1 in city An, 4 in city B, 2 in city C, 3 in city D, 1 in city G, 1 in city S, and 1 in city U) of the total 85 inpatient hospice and palliative care facilities registered with the Ministry of Health and Welfare. The study participants were those who understood the purpose of the study and consented to voluntary participation, had worked at a specialized hospice and palliative care facility for 6 months or more, had experience of end-of-life care, and completed 60 hours or more of hospice education recognized by the Ministry of Health and Welfare.
데이터처리
2) Differences in the degree of compassion fatigue by general characteristics of the participants were analyzed by the t-test and analysis of variance, and a post-hoc analysis was performed using the Scheffé test.
3) Relationships between participants’ nursing workplace spirituality, end-of-life care stress, resilience, and compassion fatigue were analyzed using Pearson correlation coefficients.
4) Stepwise multiple regression was performed to identify factors affecting compassion fatigue.
이론/모형
Compassion fatigue was assessed using a tool described by Kim [19], who adapted Stamm’s [3] Professional Quality of Life Scale version 5.0 (ProQOLS: Compassion Satisfaction/ Fatigue Subscale-version 5.0), which is a revised and supplemented version of the original tool developed by Figley [20]. The tool used in this study consists of a total of 20 items and includes two subscales (secondary traumatic stress and burn- out).
Nursing workplace spirituality was assessed using a measurement tool that Suk and Koh [12] developed for this pur- pose. The tool has a total of 32 items and is composed of six subscales including interaction with job environment, meaning of nursing, inner self, relationship with colleagues, harmony between workplace and individual, and transcendence through nursing.
Resilience was assessed using the tool proposed by Choi and Seok [22]. They modified the Korean Resilience Quotient-53 (KRQ-53) to use among adults, which Shin et al.
It is a 40-item assessment tool consisting of 7 subscales, including negative attitudes of patient and his/her family members, difficulty of sharing time to the dying patient, burden about bereavement care, overloaded duty, humane relation conflict with dying patient, insufficiency in professional knowledge and skills, and conflict about medical limit. The tool uses a 5-point Likert scale, and a higher score indicates higher end-of-life care stress. Lee and Lee [14] reported the total Cronbach’s α was 0.
성능/효과
1) General characteristics, nursing workplace spirituality, end-of-life care stress, resilience, and compassion fatigue were analyzed by descriptive statistics such as percentage, mean, and standard deviation.
First, regarding work spirituality, end-of-life care stress, resilience, and compassion fatigue among nurses working at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities, the mean score for the level of work spirituality among the nurses at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities was 4.93 points (out of 7 points), which is somewhat higher than the scores of 4.49 points among general hospital nurses reported by Kown and Oh [23], 4.59 points reported by Suk and Koh [12], and 4.13 points among hospital nurses reported by Jin et al. [9].
In this study, besides resilience, subjective health status and hospice ward satisfaction were found to have the strongest influence on compassion fatigue among nurses at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities. It is difficult to make a direct comparison due to the scarcity of research on factors influencing compassion fatigue among nurses at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities, but a similar finding was reported in a study involving intensive care unit nurses [29], in whom subjective health status affected burnout, a subscale of compassion fatigue.
In this study, the factors affecting the level of compassion fatigue among nurses at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities were resilience, subjective health status, current hospice ward satisfaction, and end-of-life care stress, with an overall explanatory power of 42.9%. Specifically, higher re- silience, higher current hospice ward satisfaction, a subjective perception of good health, and lower end-of-life care stress were associated with lower levels of compassion fatigue.
The most robust explanatory factor for compassion fatigue among nurses at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities was resilience. Due to the lack of research on the factors affecting compassion fatigue among nurses at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities, it is difficult to directly compare the results of this study, but resilience was also reported to be the most explanatory factor of burnout, a subscale of compassion fatigue, among clinical nurses in a study of Ryu and Kim [17].
후속연구
In addition, it is necessary to understand the characteristics of compassion fatigue among nurses at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities through additional studies on factors affecting compassion fatigue among these nurses. A practical compassion fatigue prevention program should be developed for nurses at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities based on comparative studies on compassion fatigue involving nurses who work at specialized facilities to provide home or outpatient hospice care, as well as inpatient hospice care.
By contrast, the results reported by Kim and Yong [28] are contradictory to the findings observed in our study: although the participants were not nurses, they found that among adult workers aged 20 years or older, workplace spirituality affected burnout, a sub scale of compassion fatigue. Therefore, in order to determine whether these conflicting results were due to differences in wards or occupations, further studies should explore the effect of nursing workplace spirituality on compassion fatigue among nurses at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities. In addition, it is our understanding that the conceptual similarity of the subscales of resilience and nursing workplace spirituality contributed to our findings that nursing workplace spirituality was correlated with compassion fatigue, but did not influence it.
Therefore, it appears that resilience is a broader concept than nursing workplace spirituality and has a greater effect on compassion fatigue. Therefore, in the future, it will be necessary to confirm the similarity between these two concepts (nursing workplace spirituality and resilience) and conduct additional studies among nurses at specialized hospice and palliative care facilities to confirm the results of the current study.
17 points). This suggests that there may be some differences in the factors that cause stress in end-of- life care depending on the ward environment, and it is thus necessary to perform additional studies to further verify these differences. In the current study, the highest score was found for stress related to “negative attitudes of patient and his/her family members”, which refers to their denial of the condition and imminent death [14].
참고문헌 (30)
1 National Cancer Center 2020 Hospice status and statistics [Internet] Available from: http://hospice.cancer.go.kr/pain/stat.do?menu_no=634&brd_mgrno= cited 2020 Jul 4
2 Kwon SH Tae YS Hong MJ Choi GH 2015 Hospice palliative nurses’ experience of caring for terminal cancer patients AON 15 264 75
3 Stamm BH 2010 The concise ProQOL manual [Internet] 2nd ed The ProQOL.org Idaho Available form: https://programs.caringsafely.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/ProQOL_Concise_2ndEd_12-2010.pdf cited 2020 Mar 26
4 Slocum-Gori S Hemsworth D Chan WW Carson A Kazanjian A 2013 Understanding compassion satisfaction, compassion fatigue and burnout: a survey of the hospice palliative care workforce Palliat Med 27 172 8 10.1177/0269216311431311 22179596
6 Cho HJ Jung MS 2014 Research trends on compassion fatigue in Korea nurses J Muscle Jt Health 21 255 64
7 Kim JI Lee TW 2016 The influence of nursing practice environment compassion fatigue and compassion satisfaction on burnout among clinical nurses J Korean Clin Nurs Res 22 109 17
8 Lee JM Yom YH 2013 Effects of work stress compassion fatigue and compassion satisfaction on burnout in clinical nurses JKANA 19 689 97
9 Jin JH Ju HO Kim KS Park YM 2017 Effects of nursing workplace spirituality on job satisfaction burnout and turnover intention among general hospital nurses J Korean Clin Nurs Res 23 142 50
10 Lee JH Park JS 2017 End of life care stress and nursing work environment in geriatric hospitals nurses affect burn out JKAIS 18 449 58
11 Kang JS Lim JY 2015 Effects of clinical nurses’ resilience on job stress and burnout JKCA 15 263 73
12 Suk JW Koh MS 2016 Development of nursing workplace spirituality instrument: confirmatory factor analysis JKANA 22 99 108
13 Hong YJ Lim SH 2017 The Impact of Palliative care practitioners’ workplace spirituality on caring for terminally ill people Kor J Fam Soc Work 57 69 98
14 Lee YO Lee HY 2005 A study of cancer unit nurses’ stress from bereavement support The 5th International Nursing Conference 2005 Oct 19-21 Seoul, Korea Korean Society of Nursing Science Seoul 229
15 Kim JH Lee HK 2012 Cancer unit nurses’ end-of-life care-related stress understanding and training needs Korean J Hosp Palliat Care 15 205 11
16 Shin WY Kim MK Kim JH 2009 Developing measures of resilience for Korean adolescents and testing cross convergent and discriminant validity Studies on Korean Youth 20 105 31
17 Ryu K Kim JK 2016 A study on relationships among resilience, stress, burnout and organizational commitment of hospital nurses JKCA 16 439 50
18 Jung SY Kim JH 2019 Influence of positive psychological capital and death awareness on terminal care performance of hematooncology unit nurses Korean J Hosp Palliat Care 22 77 86
19 Kim HJ 2010 The relationships among traumatic events, compassion fatigue, burnout and compassion satisfaction on emergency nurses [master’s thesis] Konkuk Univ. Seoul Korean
20 Figley CR 2002 Compassion fatigue: psychotherapists’ chronic lack of self care J Clin Psychol 58 1433 41 12412153
21 Reivich K Shatte A c2002 The resilience factor: 7 essential skills for overcoming life’s inevitable obstacles Broadway New York
22 Choi HJ Seok EJ 2013 An analysis of child care teachers’ resilience and job satisfaction Korean Journal of Child Care and Education 75 93 115
23 Kown KY Oh PJ 2019 Effects of nurses’ nursing workplace spirituality and self-efficacy on the patient safety management activities JKANA 25 106 14
24 Ro YJ Kang KA Ko SJ Gu YM Gu IH Kwon SH 2018 Hospice & palliative care Hyunmoon Publishing Co. Seoul
25 Lee MK 2018 The relationship between nursing workplace spirituality and resilience of clinical nurses [master’s thesis] Kosin Univ. Busan Korean
26 Kwon YE 2018 A study on emotional labor, resilience and psychological well-being of clinical nurses JKAIS 19 339 46
27 Choi YE 2013 Predictors of burnout among hospice nurses master’s thesis Kyungpook Univ. Daegu Korean
28 Kim MJ Yong HW 2016 The relation between career adaptability and job satisfaction job burnout: mediating effects of workplace spirituality Korean Journal of Counseling 17 187 204
29 Kim SR Jeon MK Hwang JH Choi AR Kim IS Pyon MK 2017 Multidimensional factors influencing burnout in intensive care unit nurses J Korean Clin Nurs Res 23 9 19
30 Park MS Kim HY Kim JY 2019 Convergence factors influencing terminal care stress in general hospital nurses JCIT 9 28 38
※ AI-Helper는 부적절한 답변을 할 수 있습니다.